Without Active Learning, You Could Fail USMLE Step 1

1721 Views
Why Active Learning is so Important for Medical Students
To pass (and nail) USMLE Step 1, memorizing the facts is just not sufficient—you must be able to apply that knowledge. While you may feel accomplished reading 50 pages of First Aid in a day, the real concern is how much of that knowledge you can actually apply. You may now be able to recognize and understand the material, but have you mastered it? The answer is no. Mastery takes time, it takes effort, and it takes active learning to successfully pass the USMLE.
The reality is that heavily using passive learning techniques in your USMLE studies put you at serious risk for a failed Step 1. Let’s be honest— just reading through First Aid may be boring, but it is also easy. Watching a USMLE Step 1 video series is even easier and it might even be enjoyable. However, these are both forms of passive learning. Passive learning, by definition, does not require students to draw connections, ask questions, or develop their own answers. All you’re doing is reading, watching, or listening to something and hoping that you’re going to magically be able to retain the information. As with most exams, passive learning just isn’t sufficient to help you avoid a failed USMLE. In fact, the easier and the more passive the studying is, the less likely you are to benefit.
Enter active learning. Active learning was first touted in the 1990’s with the development of the constructivist learning theory. This theory emphasized that individuals learn best by actively participating in their own learning: building their own knowledge, identifying their own connections between topics, and associating their existing knowledge to form an enhanced understanding (3). As such, active learning is defined as activities done by students to construct knowledge and understanding. They require higher order thinking, also known as, “metacognition.” These activities can range from tutoring peers on a tough concept to challenging your knowledge through question sets, to taking notes and making flashcards while going through First Aid for USMLE Step 1. Active learning is the best chance you have at passing Step 1– rather than failing.
Additionally, there is a mountain of evidence supporting the benefit of active learning that stretches back thirty years. In one metanalysis of 225 studies comparing passive and active learning, they found students in traditional lectures were 1.5x more likely to fail than students engaged in active learning (4)! Another benefit of active learning is it mitigates the drop-off in concentration often seen after just 15 minutes of passive learning.
So how do you integrate active learning into your Step 1 schedule? Here are just a few strategies:
- Summarize hard concepts– e.g., after answering a uWorld, summarize the question in one sentence with the salient details and the answer choice in one or two sentences (1)
- Retrieve practice– e.g., after reviewing half of the endocrine section of FirstAid, take 10 minutes and physically write down everything you can remember, then compare. Another way is to produce an answer to a USMLE question without scanning the answer choices (2)
- Generate your own questions– e.g., after continuing to get questions on the micturition reflex wrong, develop your own questions and answers to cover the concept
- Develop concept maps– e.g., create your own concept trees to identify what clinical characteristics and diagnostics tests distinguish different autoimmune arthropathies (5,6)
- Interweave subjects- e.g., learning about hypersensitivity reactions by studying the pathophysiology of Goodpasture’s disease. This technique converts important information from short- to long-term memory
*Of Note:
In the context of studying for USMLE Step 1, active learning is not enough—it must be paired with space repetition. Spaced repetition is the idea of learning a bundle of material once, and then reviewing it a designated time later in your study period so you don’t “lose it.” For example, learning how to read an EKG for one hour, reviewing that material for 30 minutes the following day, reviewing it for 15 minutes the next week. This ensures long-term retainment of knowledge.
It is also worth noting that the above strategies are especially relevant moving into the future as USMLE Step 1 goes pass/fail. As schools and students alike may regard Step 1 as “easier” after January 2022 due to its shift away from a numeric score, it is critically important that studying is still taken seriously. A failed Step 1 exam has always had potentially serious consequences. This is not to say that it’s impossible to bounce back from a failure, however, successfully passing the USMLE on your first attempt is in important step in landing the residency of your dreams. Even if a numberic Step 1 score will no longer exist, meaning you don’t have to go crazy trying to get a 260, you are sorely mistaken if you think that Step 1 is set to become an exam you can pass by just flipping through First Aid.
Further, integrating the strategies above into your study schedule may feel tedious or like extra work, but they are worthwhile. Step 1 is important, so make your studying productive and effective!
- Bonwell, C. C., and Eison, J.A. (1991). Active learning: creating excitement in the classroom. ASH#-ERIC Higher Education Report No. 1, Washington, D.C.: The George Washington University, School of Education and Human Development.
- Brame, C.J. and Biel, R. (2015). Test-enhanced learning: the potential for testing to promote greater learning in undergraduate science courses. CBE Life Sciences Education, 14, 1-12.
- Bransford, J.D., Brown, A.L., and Cocking, R.R. (Eds.) (1999). How people learn: Brain, mind, experience, and school. Washington, D.C.: National Academy Press
- Freeman, S., Eddy, S.L., McDonough, M., Smith, M.K., Okoroafor, N., Jordt, H., and Wenderoth, M.P. (2014). Active learning increases student performance in science, engineering, and mathematics. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 111, 8410-8415.
- Handelsman, J., Miller, S., and Pfund, C. (2007). Scientific teaching. New York: W.H. Freeman.
- Novak, J.D. and Canas, A.J. (2008). The theory underlying concept maps and how to construct and use them. Technical Report IHMC.
Need additional
help with your exam?
Enter your info to hear from a member of our team and discuss if 1-on-1 tutoring is right for you.
About the Author
Danielle Marshall, MD
In 2012, Danielle Marshall graduated from the University of California, Berkeley with a BA in Cellular Biology and a minor in Global Poverty. Shortly after,…
Read MoreNever Miss an Article!
Sign up to our newsletter and get the best of Elite Medical Prep, tailored for you.
Featured Articles
Elite Medical Prep
How to Make Memory Palaces in Medical School
Elite Medical Prep
How to Study for the Internal Medicine Shelf Exam
Elite Medical Prep
What are Memory Palaces?
Elite Medical Prep
5 More New NBME Practice Exams Are Coming
Elite Medical Prep
Everything About UWorld’s ABFM QBank
Elite Medical Prep
Dealing With Test Anxiety During Medical School
Elite Medical Prep
5 Biggest Mistakes Students Make While Studying for USMLE Step 1
Elite Medical Prep
How To Triage Reviewing for ABSITE and USMLE Step 3
Elite Medical Prep
Things IMGs Can Do to Improve Their Chance of US Residency Matching
Elite Medical Prep
Aim High or Just Pass USMLE Step 1 in 2021
Elite Medical Prep
A Complete Guide to Getting Through the UWorld QBank Twice
Elite Medical Prep
Elite Medical Prep Co-Founder Receives COVID-19 Vaccine
Elite Medical Prep
What to Do the Day Before Your USMLE Step 1 Exam
Elite Medical Prep
Why Basic Sciences Are Still Important During Preclinical Studies
Elite Medical Prep
COMLEX Level 1 to Become Pass/Fail!
Elite Medical Prep
Common ABSITE Question Types You’ll Encounter on the Exam
Elite Medical Prep
How I Used My UWorld Subscription for MS1 and MS2
Elite Medical Prep
Options for a Low ABSITE Score
Elite Medical Prep
How to Study for USMLE Step 2CS
Elite Medical Prep
2021 USMLE Step 1 and Step 2 CK Score Percentiles
Elite Medical Prep
How to Simultaneously Study for Step 2 CK and Your Shelf Exams
Elite Medical Prep
5 Things US IMGs Should Know When Applying to Residency
Elite Medical Prep
Questions You Should Ask Your Prospective Residency Programs
Elite Medical Prep
How to Create an ABSITE Study Schedule
Elite Medical Prep
A Quick User’s Guide to Pathoma for USMLE Step 1
Elite Medical Prep
How to Write a Personal Statement Hook
Elite Medical Prep
When is it Time to Get a USMLE Step 1 or Step 2 Tutor?
Elite Medical Prep
UWorld in 30 Days: Making the Most out of UWorld’s Most Basic Subscription
Elite Medical Prep
Here’s How Residency Programs Rank Applicants
Elite Medical Prep
The Ins and Outs of Virtual Residency Application Season
Elite Medical Prep
How to Use the AAMC Residency Explorer Tool
Elite Medical Prep
Residency Matching: How to Cancel an Interview the Right Way
Elite Medical Prep
Post Interview Communication: The Residency Thank You Letter
Elite Medical Prep
So You Want to Be a Neurologist
Elite Medical Prep
An Interview with NBME Free 120 Explanation Guru: Ben White
Elite Medical Prep
5 Effective Study Tips to Help You Prepare for COMLEX Level 1
Elite Medical Prep
What to Look For in a Residency Program
Elite Medical Prep
USMLE Step 1 Practice Question Types
Elite Medical Prep
When to Start Studying for USMLE Step 1
Elite Medical Prep
5 Most Productive Study Tips for USMLE Step 1
Elite Medical Prep
Why Spaced Repetition is SO Important for USMLE Studies?
Elite Medical Prep
Taking USMLE Step 1 with Step 2CK After Rotations
Elite Medical Prep
How to Study for COMLEX Level 2-CE
Elite Medical Prep
My Experience Taking the USMLE during COVID-19
Elite Medical Prep
Most Common Reasons for Failing USMLE Step 1
Elite Medical Prep
USMLE Step 2CS is Cancelled
Elite Medical Prep
How to Manage USMLE Step 1 Test Anxiety
Elite Medical Prep
When to Start UWorld for USMLE Step 1
Elite Medical Prep
How to Best Use First Aid USMLE Step 1 to Study
Elite Medical Prep
WEBINAR: Tutoring Program Best Practices for Institutions
Elite Medical Prep
NBME Updates: Free Assessments & Explanations
Elite Medical Prep
Without Active Learning, You Could Fail USMLE Step 1
Elite Medical Prep
Elite Medical Prep Founder Delivers Grand Rounds at University of Hawaii
Elite Medical Prep
WEBINAR: COVID-19 Imaging for Medical Students & Residents
Elite Medical Prep
How to Painlessly Prepare for USMLE Step 3 & COMLEX Level 3
Elite Medical Prep
Medical School Closed Due to Coronavirus? Remote Learning Tips
Elite Medical Prep
Everything Changed – COVID-19 From a 1st Year Resident’s View
Elite Medical Prep
Pushing Back your USMLE Test Date Without Losing Knowledge
Elite Medical Prep
What COVID-19 Means for Medical Students
Elite Medical Prep
All United States Prometric Testing Centers CLOSED
Elite Medical Prep
How to Study for the American Board of Internal Medicine Exam
Elite Medical Prep
How USMLE Step 1 Going Pass/Fail Will Affect Medical School Curricula
Elite Medical Prep
How USMLE Step 1 Going Pass/Fail Will Affect DO students
Elite Medical Prep
How USMLE Step 1 Going Pass/Fail Will Affect IMGs
Elite Medical Prep
USMLE Step 1 to Become Pass/Fail
Elite Medical Prep
COMLEX Level 1 to USMLE Step 1 Predictor
Elite Medical Prep
Mistakes Students Make With First Aid for USMLE Step 1
Elite Medical Prep
Best COMLEX Level 2-CE Study Resources
Elite Medical Prep
Essential Tips for Excelling on the ABIM Certification Exam
Elite Medical Prep
Best COMLEX Level 1 Study Resources
Elite Medical Prep
How to Score 260 on USMLE Step 1
Elite Medical Prep
5 Tips on Studying for Step 3
Elite Medical Prep
Best Ways to Study for Step 2CK
Elite Medical Prep
COMLEX Level 1 Exam Blueprint and the AOA ACGME Merger
Elite Medical Prep
How to Score a 280 on USMLE Step 2 CK
Elite Medical Prep
UWorld vs. TrueLearn
Elite Medical Prep
How to Study for USMLE Step 1 During MS2
Elite Medical Prep
Matching Into Orthopaedic Surgery Residency
Elite Medical Prep
Matching into Thoracic Surgery Residency
Elite Medical Prep
How to Match into OB/GYN Residency
Elite Medical Prep
How to Match into a Vascular Surgery Residency Program in 2021
Elite Medical Prep
What You Need to Match Into MED/PEDS for Residency
Elite Medical Prep
Acceptance Factors for Matching into Internal Medicine Residency
Elite Medical Prep
Acceptance Factors for Matching into Plastic Surgery Residency
Elite Medical Prep
How to Match into an ENT Residency Program 2021
Elite Medical Prep
Acceptance Factors for Matching into Pediatrics Residency
Elite Medical Prep
Acceptance Factors for Matching into Radiology for Residency
Elite Medical Prep
How to Match into a Neurology Residency Program
Elite Medical Prep
What You Need to Match into Emergency Medicine for Residency
Elite Medical Prep
What You Need to Match into Psychiatry for Residency
Elite Medical Prep
Acceptance Factors for Matching into a Transitional Year (TY) Residency
Elite Medical Prep
What You Need to Match into Family Medicine for Residency
Elite Medical Prep
How to Match into a Dermatology Residency Program in 2021
Elite Medical Prep
Acceptance Factors for Matching into Anesthesia for Residency
Elite Medical Prep
Will I Match into My Residency Specialty of Choice?
Elite Medical Prep
Scheduling Residency Interviews
Elite Medical Prep
Studying for USMLE Step 1 During MS1
Elite Medical Prep
Saving Money on Residency Applications
Elite Medical Prep
Preparing for Your Residency Interview
Elite Medical Prep
The Elite Medical Prep Anki Biochem Deck
Elite Medical Prep
Journey to Orthopedics Residency- Interviews
Elite Medical Prep
Why QBanks are a CRUCIAL Part of Your USMLE Review
Elite Medical Prep
Failing USMLE Step 1: What to Do
Elite Medical Prep
How to Write Your ERAS Personal Statement
Elite Medical Prep
How to Write the MSPE
Elite Medical Prep
Your 10 Week USMLE Step 1 Study Schedule
Elite Medical Prep
Applying Into Pathology Residency
Elite Medical Prep
How to Score Above 270 on USMLE Step 1
Elite Medical Prep
Applying to ENT Residency
Elite Medical Prep
How to Make Your Residency Rank List
Elite Medical Prep
Entering Week 3 at Mount Sinai Medical School
Elite Medical Prep
Elite Medical Prep Course at Mount Sinai
Elite Medical Prep
How Many Residency Programs & Where to Apply
Elite Medical Prep
Using Flashcards to Study for the USMLE
Elite Medical Prep
Using Brosencephalon Effectively for USMLE Studying
Elite Medical Prep
6 Tips on Using Anki USMLE Flashcards
Elite Medical Prep
Benefits and Drawbacks of Zanki Deck for USMLE Step 1 Studies
Elite Medical Prep
New NBMEs- Our Professional Opinion
Elite Medical Prep
2021 Free 6 Week USMLE Step 1 Study Schedule
Elite Medical Prep
Let’s Talk NBMEs! Free Webinar Sunday, March 31st @3pm EST/noon PST
Elite Medical Prep
Takeaways You Can Expect From the New NBME Forms
Elite Medical Prep
Using the UWSA Practice Tests After New NBME Releases
Elite Medical Prep
Using the Old NBME Exam Forms Before They Are ‘Retired’
Elite Medical Prep
Planning to Use the New NBME Practice Forms
Elite Medical Prep
Residency Letters of Recommendation: Everything You Need to Know
Elite Medical Prep
How to Use the ERAS (Electronic Residency Application Service)
Elite Medical Prep
Residency Application Timeline: What To Do When
Elite Medical Prep
Amboss Review: USMLE Prep Platforms
Elite Medical Prep
Online MedEd: USMLE Prep Platform Reviews
Elite Medical Prep
Pathoma: USMLE Prep Platform Reviews
Elite Medical Prep
Kaplan: USMLE Prep Platform Reviews
Elite Medical Prep
Osmosis: USMLE Prep Platform Reviews
Elite Medical Prep
Lecturio: USMLE Prep Platform Reviews
Elite Medical Prep
What if I fail? Bouncing back on the USMLE Step 1
Elite Medical Prep
What Makes a Great USMLE Tutoring Service?
Elite Medical Prep
How to Score Above 240 on USMLE Step 1
Elite Medical Prep
The Ultimate USMLE Step 2 Study Guide
Elite Medical Prep
What is the USMLE Exam?
Elite Medical Prep
Flash Facts: USMLE Flashcard Resource Reviews
Elite Medical Prep
Brosencephalon: USMLE Flashcard Reviews
Elite Medical Prep
Firecracker: USMLE Flashcard Resource Reviews
Elite Medical Prep
Zanki: USMLE Flashcard Resource Reviews
Elite Medical Prep